Italian Restaurants in Pittsburgh

Italian Restaurants in Pittsburgh

When it comes to Italian cuisine in Pittsburgh, there are numerous restaurants that offer a taste of Italy’s rich culinary traditions. From cozy trattorias to upscale eateries, the city boasts a diverse array of Italian restaurants that cater to various preferences. 


This article explores the 15 best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh, highlighting their strengths and what makes them stand out. Whether you’re craving wood-fired pizzas, or traditional Italian comfort food, these restaurants are sure to satisfy your appetite for authentic Italian flavors.

Italian Restaurants in Pittsburgh

From the brick oven pizzas at Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room to the refined dishes at Joseph Tambellini, here are the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh:


1. Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room

Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room
Image source: pittsburghbeautiful
Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room

Known for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, Proper Brick Oven and Tap Room offers a unique dining experience.

Their brick oven pizzas are cooked at high temperatures, resulting in a perfectly crispy crust with delicious toppings. In addition to their pizzas, they also have a great selection of craft beers on tap, making it a popular spot for beer enthusiasts.

2. Pizzaiolo Primo

Pizzaiolo Primo
Image source: Pizzaiolo Primo

Pizzaiolo Primo is a charming Italian restaurant that focuses on traditional Italian flavors and techniques. Their pasta dishes are handmade and cooked to perfection, with rich and flavorful sauces.

The menu also features a variety of seafood and meat options, all prepared with care and attention to detail. The cozy atmosphere and attentive service add to the overall dining experience.


3. Sienna Mercato

Sienna Mercato
Image source: aasiennamercato
Sienna Mercato

Sienna Mercato is a multi-level Italian marketplace offering a range of dining options. The first floor features a vibrant meatball-focused restaurant, while the second floor offers a rustic Italian experience with wood-fired pizzas and pasta dishes.

On the rooftop, you’ll find a beer garden with stunning views of the city. Sienna Mercato provides a diverse dining experience that caters to different tastes.

4. Piccolo Forno

Piccolo Forno
Image source: christina
Piccolo Forno

This cozy Italian trattoria is known for its rustic and authentic Italian dishes. The wood-fired pizzas are a highlight, with thin crusts and fresh toppings.


Their pasta dishes are also noteworthy, with homemade sauces and perfectly cooked al dente noodles. The intimate setting and friendly service make Piccolo Forno a favorite among locals.

5. Enrico Biscotti Co

Enrico Biscotti Co
Image source: postlmg
Enrico Biscotti Co

Enrico Biscotti Co is a charming bakery and cafe that also serves Italian cuisine. Their menu includes a variety of paninis, salads, and pasta dishes.

However, their true specialty lies in their freshly baked biscotti and pastries. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or a sweet treat, Enrico Biscotti Co offers a delightful experience.


6. Cucina Vitale

Cucina Vitale
Image source: cubacafe
Cucina Vitale

Cucina Vitale is a family-owned restaurant that prides itself on serving traditional Italian comfort food. Their menu features classic dishes like lasagna, chicken Parmesan, and homemade gnocchi.

The portions are generous, and the flavors are hearty and satisfying. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes Cucina Vitale a great choice for a cozy Italian meal.

7. Vallozzi’s Pittsburgh

Vallozzi's Pittsburgh
Image source: vallozzis
Vallozzi’s Pittsburgh

Vallozzi’s Pittsburgh offers an upscale Italian dining experience with a modern twist. The restaurant’s elegant decor and attentive service create a sophisticated ambiance.


The menu showcases a fusion of traditional Italian flavors with innovative presentations. From handmade pastas to expertly cooked steaks, Vallozzi’s delivers a memorable dining experience.

8. Legends Eatery

Legends Eatery
Image source:
Legends Eatery

Legends Eatery is a hidden gem for Italian cuisine in Pittsburgh. The restaurant focuses on serving homemade Italian classics using fresh and high-quality ingredients.

Their menu includes a range of pasta dishes, seafood options, and delicious desserts. The cozy and casual atmosphere, combined with the flavorful dishes, keeps patrons coming back for more.



9. Centi Anni Alla Famiglia

Centi Anni Alla Famiglia
Image source: thrillist
Centi Anni Alla Famiglia

Centi Anni Alla Famiglia is a family-friendly Italian restaurant that offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Their menu features a variety of Italian favorites, including pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches.

The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable, making it a popular choice for families and groups.

10. Girasole Restaurant

Girasole Restaurant
Image source: pinterest
Girasole Restaurant

Girasole Restaurant offers an elegant and intimate dining experience. The menu focuses on Northern Italian cuisine, with dishes like risotto, osso buco, and homemade pastas.

The chef’s attention to detail and the use of fresh, seasonal ingredients shine through in each dish. The restaurant’s cozy ambiance and knowledgeable staff make it a perfect choice for a special occasion.

11. Mercurio’s

Image source: yellowpages

Mercurio’s is a family-owned Italian restaurant that specializes in wood-fired pizzas and homemade gelato. Their thin-crust pizzas are cooked to perfection, with a variety of toppings to choose from.

The gelato, made in-house, comes in a wide range of flavors and is a perfect way to end the meal. The casual and friendly atmosphere makes Mercurio’s a favorite among pizza lovers.

12. Big Jim’s Restaurant & Bar

Big Jim's Restaurant & Bar
Image source: bigjimssteaks
Big Jim’s

Big Jim’s is a casual Italian-American restaurant that offers a diverse menu with a focus on hearty portions.

Their menu includes classic dishes like spaghetti and meatballs, chicken Alfredo, and calzones. The relaxed atmosphere and friendly service make it a great spot for a casual Italian meal with friends or family.

13. Mineo’s Pizza House 

Mineo's Pizza House
Image source: onebite
Mineo’s Pizza House

Mineo’s Pizza House is a local institution known for its New York-style pizzas. The thin crusts are topped with a generous amount of cheese and a variety of toppings.

The pizza is cooked to perfection, resulting in a delicious combination of flavors. It’s a great place to grab a slice or a whole pie when you’re craving authentic, mouthwatering pizza.

14. Joseph Tambellini 

 Joseph Tambellini 
Image source: goodfoodpittsburgh
Joseph Tambellini

Joseph Tambellini is an upscale Italian restaurant that offers a refined dining experience. The menu features a blend of traditional and modern Italian dishes, prepared with high-quality ingredients.

From fresh seafood to homemade pastas, each dish is expertly crafted and beautifully presented. The attentive service and elegant ambiance make Joseph Tambellini a top choice for a special night out.

15. Bravo! Italian Kitchen 

Bravo! Italian Kitchen
Image source: bravoitalian
Bravo! Italian Kitchen

Bravo! Italian Kitchen is a popular chain restaurant that offers a casual and family-friendly atmosphere. The menu features a variety of Italian dishes, including pasta, pizzas, and salads.

While it may not be the most authentic Italian restaurant on the list, Bravo! Italian Kitchen is known for its consistent quality and generous portions, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying Italian meal.


Pittsburgh’s Italian dining scene is thriving, with a wide range of restaurants that excel in serving delectable Italian cuisine. Each restaurant on this list offers a unique experience and showcases the artistry and flavors of Italian cooking. 

So whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a visitor seeking an authentic taste of Italy, these 15 Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh are sure to impress with their culinary expertise, warm hospitality, and dedication to delivering a memorable dining experience.