Italian Restaurants in Sarasota

Top 10 Italian Restaurants in Sarasota

Sarasota, known for its beautiful beaches and vibrant cultural scene, is also home to outstanding Italian restaurants. Are you craving traditional pasta dishes, authentic Neapolitan pizzas, or innovative creations with an Italian flair? Sarasota has it all. 

Below are the top 10 Italian restaurants in Sarasota, highlighting their strengths and what makes them stand out. 

From cozy and family-owned establishments to trendy and modern hotspots, these restaurants offer a wide range of culinary experiences that will transport you to the heart of Italy. 

Top Italian Restaurants in Sarasota

Get ready to embark on a delicious journey as we uncover the finest Italian restaurants in Sarasota.

1. Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano

Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano
Image source: opentable
Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano

Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano restaurant offers a true taste of Italy with its authentic Italian cuisine. The pasta dishes are cooked to perfection, and the seafood options are fresh and flavorful.

The restaurant has a cozy and inviting atmosphere, and the service is attentive and friendly.

The wine selection is extensive, featuring a variety of Italian wines that pair well with the dishes. Overall, Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano excels in providing an authentic Italian dining experience.

2. Bavaro’s

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria
Image source: edge

Known for its delicious Neapolitan-style pizzas, Bavaro’s is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. The pizza dough is made using traditional methods and cooked in a wood-fired oven, resulting in a thin, crispy crust with a delightful chewiness.

The restaurant also offers a range of pasta dishes that are made with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavors. The casual and lively ambiance adds to the overall dining experience, making Bavaro’s a popular spot for families and friends.

3. Bevardi’s Salute

Bevardi's Salute
Image source: mustseesarasota
Bevardi’s Salute

Bevardi’s Salute is a charming Italian restaurants in Sarasota, known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere. The menu features a mix of traditional Italian dishes and innovative creations.

The homemade pasta dishes are particularly noteworthy, as they are cooked al dente and served with flavorful sauces.

The wine list offers a great selection of Italian wines to complement the dishes. With attentive service and a cozy ambiance, Bevardi’s Salute is a fantastic choice for a memorable Italian meal.

4. La Mucca Ballerina

La Mucca Ballerina
Image source: opentable
La Mucca Ballerina

La Mucca Ballerina is a hidden gem in Sarasota, offering a delightful culinary experience. The restaurant’s focus is on using locally sourced ingredients to create authentic Italian flavors. The menu changes seasonally, ensuring fresh and vibrant dishes.

The presentation of the food is artistic and the flavors are carefully balanced. The staff is knowledgeable and passionate about Italian cuisine, providing excellent recommendations.

La Mucca Ballerina is a must-try for those seeking a unique and memorable Italian dining experience.

5. Flavio Downtown Sarasota

Flavio Downtown Sarasota
Image source: flaviosonmain
Flavio Downtown Sarasota

Flavio Downtown Sarasota is a modern Italian restaurants in Sarasota, that impresses with its contemporary twist on classic Italian dishes. The menu features a wide range of options, from handmade pasta to creative seafood and meat dishes.

The restaurant’s stylish and elegant decor creates a sophisticated ambiance. The service is attentive and knowledgeable, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.

Flavio Downtown Sarasota is an excellent choice for those looking for a modern take on Italian cuisine.


6. Cafe Amici

Cafe Amici
Image source: cafeamiciwyckoff
Cafe Amici

Cafe Amici is a cozy Italian restaurants in Sarasota, that offers a relaxed and friendly atmosphere. The menu showcases classic Italian dishes prepared with fresh and high-quality ingredients. The pasta dishes are flavorful, and the wood-fired pizzas are a crowd favorite.

The restaurant also offers a good selection of Italian wines and desserts. The staff provides excellent service, making you feel like a valued guest. Cafe Amici is a popular choice for casual Italian dining in Sarasota.

7. 481 Gourmet

481 Gourmet
Image source: opentable
481 Gourmet

481 Gourmet is a hidden gem that specializes in artisanal Italian cuisine. The restaurant focuses on creating dishes with unique flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients.

The menu is constantly evolving, showcasing the chef’s creativity and passion for Italian flavors. From homemade pastas to delectable desserts, every dish is a culinary delight.

The intimate and cozy setting adds to the overall experience. If you’re looking for a distinctive and memorable Italian dining experience, 481 Gourmet is worth a visit.

8. Cafe Gabbiano

Cafe Gabbiano
Image source: cafegabbiano
Cafe Gabbiano

Cafe Gabbiano is a charming Italian restaurant known for its romantic ambiance and traditional Italian dishes. The restaurant sources fresh ingredients to create flavorful and authentic meals.

The extensive wine list offers a variety of Italian wines to pair with the dishes. The attentive and friendly staff ensures that every visit is enjoyable. Cafe Gabbiano is a great choice for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.

9. Ama la Vita Ristorante

Ama la Vita Ristorante
Image source: ubereats
Ama la Vita

Ama la Vita Ristorante is a popular Italian restaurant that combines a modern setting with traditional Italian flavors. The menu offers a wide range of dishes, including handmade pasta, fresh seafood, and tender meat options.

The restaurant’s attention to detail is evident in the presentation and taste of each dish. The service is attentive and knowledgeable, and the restaurant has a lively and vibrant atmosphere.

Ama la Vita Ristorante is a go-to spot for those seeking a modern and delicious Italian dining experience.

10. Casantica Ristorante

Casantica Ristorante
Image source: mustseesarasota
Casantica Ristorante

Casantica Ristorante is a family-owned Italian restaurant known for its warm hospitality and homestyle cooking. The menu features classic Italian dishes prepared with love and attention to detail. The pasta is made in-house and the sauces are rich and flavorful.

The portions are generous, and the prices are reasonable. The cozy and intimate atmosphere adds to the overall charm of the restaurant. Casantica Ristorante is a favorite among locals for its authentic and comforting Italian cuisine.


Sarasota truly boasts an impressive array of Italian restaurants, each with its own unique charm and culinary specialties. 

From the authentic flavors of Mediterraneo Ristorante Italiano to the inventive creations at Flavio Downtown Sarasota. These top 10 Italian restaurants have proven their excellence in providing exceptional dining experiences.